Bringing PE mid-market opportunities to all investors

As featured in Money Management. View the original article here.
With a well-established portfolio, deliberately constructed since its launch in 2019, and an increasing number of investments reaching realisation, the Pengana Private Equity Trust (PE1) has refreshed its strategy to reflect the portfolio’s growing maturity, while continuing to capitalise on attractive opportunities in the global mid-market private equity sector.
The strategy, which is managed by the US$97 billion alternative investment manager GCM Grosvenor, provides investors with access to a globally diversified portfolio of private equity investments.
“Access to these opportunities requires significant scale, established relationships and deep expertise. It’s simply not something investors can replicate on their own,” Pengana executive director Adam Myers said.
PE1’s objective is to generate attractive long-term returns and capital growth, primarily through private equity investments, complemented by a smaller allocation to private credit where appropriate.
It targets investments in established and economically resilient mid-market businesses across sectors such as industrials, financial services, healthcare, technology and consumer products.
The preference for mid-market companies stems from the significantly larger investment universe, less competition, and opportunities to acquire businesses at more attractive valuations and generally with less leverage than can be achieved in the mega-cap space.There is also a larger range of potential exit strategies so these businesses are less reliant on a favourable IPO environment.
Over the years, the PE1 portfolio has been built through a range of private equity investment approaches including co-investments, direct investments, primary funds, and secondary investments, providing diversification across investment managers, geographic regions and investment vintages.
“These are generally businesses where value creation is driven by growing earnings and improving operations, rather than simply relying on higher valuation multiples.”
One of the firm’s most-successful investments has been a six-year investment in Elon Musk’s SpaceX which floated on the Nasdaq in June. PE1’s high conviction in the investment led to an initial allocation of almost 2 per cent of the portfolio. The investment subsequently appreciated to more than 10 times its original cost, becoming the largest individual company exposure in the portfolio. This position is now being progressively sold down, turning the appreciation into cash.
Adviser due diligence
For some advisers, private equity vehicles may be a new component for a client’s portfolio and Pengana agrees there are additional elements of due diligence needed compared to public holdings.
As with all private equity investing, the underlying assets are generally illiquid and are intended to be held over multiple years although material investments such as with SpaceX can materially influence performance over the shorter-term. Private company valuations are ordinarily based on the latest available valuations provided by underlying managers, which are generally reported quarterly with a quarter lag.
A major due diligence consideration is around the consistency of a fund’s performance over the years.
“They say ‘past performance is no guarantee of future performance’ and nowhere is that more true than in private equity. If you take a top quartile fund and then look at successive fund vintages, they could sit in any quartile.
“You have to look at the forward-looking factors, such as how they create value and if their strategy and expertise is appropriate for the current environment, team stability, team alignment, how much money they raise, and whether they are sector specialists or generalists.
“The other thing you don’t want is too much concentration. A single manager, no matter how good they are, can get things wrong, back the wrong companies, invest at a bad time, or concentrate on the wrong sectors. If you want to get the long-term benefits of private equity then we think that is best achieved in a diversified portfolio approach.”
A refreshed strategy
In October, the firm made several changes to reflect the maturity of its portfolio and the increasing volume of realised investments returning capital to the Trust. This included increased distributions to at least 6 per cent per annum paid quarterly, a clearer investment objective with a 10–14 per cent per annum target return over the long-term, greater emphasis on co-investments and direct investments, updated portfolio allocation framework and more flexible capital management initiatives.
Having established a solid foundation, the strategy is expected to access private equity primarily through co-investments and direct investments going forward which offer greater opportunities for individual investment selection and potential fee efficiencies.
Regarding the clearer investment framework, Myers elaborated: “When PE1 launched, diversification was a priority. The trust now has an extremely diversified portfolio and hasexposure to hundreds of economically-resilient businesses. Now what we want is the ability to identify and commit to the next great opportunity.”
PE1 retains its on-market buyback as a capital management tool, but future buybacks will be undertaken opportunistically rather than through the previous formulaic framework linked to the discount to NAV, to allow the Trust to balance returning capital to investors with maintaining sufficient commitments to attractive long-term private equity investments.
The target cash distribution yield has also increased from 4 per cent of NAV per annum to at least 6 per cent of NAV per annum and distributions are moving from semi-annual to quarterly payments, equating to an indicative yield of 7.7 per cent on the late October ASX share price, assuming the September NAV remains unchanged at $1.867 per unit.
“The discount is the cherry on the top,” Myers said.
Important Disclosures
Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance, the value of investments can go up and down. The net return has been determined with reference to the increase in the Net Asset Value per Unit, as well as of the reinvestment of a Unit’s distribution back into the Trust pursuant to the Trust’s distribution reinvestment plan (“DRP”). Pengana has established a DRP in respect of distributions made by the Trust. Under the DRP, Unitholders may elect to have all or part of their distribution reinvested in additional Units.
Pengana intends to target a cash distribution yield of at least 6% p.a. (prorated on a non-compounded basis) of the NAV (including the cash distribution amount payable) as at the end of the period that a distribution relates to. The targeted distribution is only a target and may not be achieved. Investors should read the Risks summary set out in Section 11 of the IPO PDS.
The NAV return target is only a target and may not be achieved.
Pengana Investment Management Limited (Pengana) (ABN 69 063 081 612, AFSL 219 462) is the issuer of units in the Pengana Private Equity Trust (ARSN 630 923 643) (the Trust). Before acting on any information contained within this report a person should consider the appropriateness of the information, having regard to their objectives, financial situation and needs.
None of Pengana, Grosvenor Capital Management, L.P. (Grosvenor), or their related entities, directors, partners or officers guarantees the performance of, or the repayment of capital, or income invested in the Trust. An investment in the Trust is subject to investment risk including a possible delay in repayment and loss of income and principal invested.
None of Pengana Private Equity Trust (“PE1”), Pengana Investment Management Limited (ABN 69 063 081 612, AFSL 219 462) (“Responsible Entity”), Grosvenor Capital Management, L.P., nor any of their related entities guarantees the repayment of capital or any particular rate of return from PE1. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance, the value of investments can go up and down. This document has been prepared by the Responsible Entity and does not take into account a reader’s investment objectives, particular needs or financial situation. It is general information only and should not be considered investment advice and should not be relied on as an investment recommendation.